If you’ve ever been caught up in the whirlwind of diet culture, you know how persuasive some nutrition trends can be. From restrictive diets like keto and carnivore to veganism, the rise of extreme eating plans in recent years feels less like a trend and more like a movement. But what happens when these diets stop being just a way of eating and start to feel like they’ve taken over your life?
In this post, we’ll explore how some restrictive diets take on cult-like qualities, manipulating emotions, forming tight-knit communities, and isolating members from alternative views. Drawing parallels between cult behavior and diet culture can help you critically evaluate your relationship with these eating plans—and maybe even break free from the extremes.
The Psychology of Restrictive Diets: Manipulation, Community, and Identity
The foundation of both cults and restrictive diets lies in psychological manipulation. We’re all familiar with the way diets prey on insecurities—about weight, appearance, or health—but some diets go even further by tapping into more primal human needs, like community and identity.
One of the first ways restrictive diets pull people in is by creating a strong sense of community. Humans are social creatures, and we crave belonging. Diets like keto or veganism don’t just provide a framework for eating—they create communities where people feel supported, validated, and connected with others who share their goals. While this might seem harmless, the problem arises when these communities become exclusive echo chambers.
Take the “us vs. them” mentality, for example. Many extreme diets position themselves as the ultimate path to health, often casting other ways of eating as wrong or even immoral. By fostering a radical message, these diets elevate their members to feel superior to those who don’t follow their plan. It’s this very dynamic that transforms a simple way of eating into something that can start to feel like a belief system.
The Danger of Groupthink and Confirmation Bias
In these diet communities, groupthink often emerges. People prioritize consensus over critical thinking, suppressing dissenting views in order to maintain harmony within the group. This makes it even harder to step back and evaluate the validity of the diet’s claims.
Confirmation bias also comes into play. People actively seek out stories and information that support their chosen diet, while ignoring or dismissing any evidence that contradicts their beliefs. This reinforces their commitment to the diet and further isolates them from alternative viewpoints. As a result, a restrictive diet that may have been beneficial at first becomes deeply entrenched in their identity, making it harder to change.
How Diets Manipulate Identity, Guilt, and Fear
It’s not just the sense of community that keeps people hooked on restrictive diets—it’s also the way these diets become intertwined with self-identity. You’ve probably seen people on social media with handles like @KetoKacie or @VeganVeronica. While sharing your passion for a diet online isn’t inherently harmful, the danger lies in how these eating styles become central to people’s identities. When your way of eating defines who you are, it can be incredibly difficult to step away from that diet, even when it’s no longer serving you.
Restrictive diets also use guilt and fear to manipulate people. Vegans, for example, might use guilt about animal suffering to convince others to give up meat. On the flip side, carnivores or keto advocates may scare people into thinking that eating carbs will undo all their health progress. These emotions—guilt and fear—are powerful motivators that can keep people stuck in unhealthy patterns or prevent them from exploring more balanced approaches.
When Diets Go Too Far: Isolation from Mainstream Science
One of the clearest signs that a diet is crossing into cult-like territory is when it rejects mainstream science. We see this happening in extreme diets like carnivore, where followers claim that well-established nutritional guidelines are part of a “Big Food” conspiracy designed to keep us sick. This rejection of science further isolates followers and creates a distrust of any information that doesn’t align with the diet’s teachings.
This mentality leads to dangerous re-education tactics. Followers of extreme diets are told to throw out everything they’ve ever learned about nutrition and adopt the pseudoscience that supports the diet. While there may be anecdotal stories of success, the lack of long-term, large-scale studies means that these diets are often built on shaky foundations.
Protecting Yourself from the Cult-Like Pull of Diet Culture
So how can you protect yourself from getting swept into the cult of diet culture? Here are a few tips to help you maintain a balanced, healthy perspective:
Be wary of charismatic individuals pushing restrictive diets, even if they claim to be backed by science. Long-term evidence currently supports balanced diets, not extreme restrictions.
Understand the pros and cons of any diet. Restrictive eating can lead to nutritional deficiencies, so if you do follow one, ensure you’re supplementing accordingly.
Be cautious of extremist views. If someone claims their diet is the “only” way to achieve optimal health, take a step back and question the bias behind that claim.
At the end of the day, it’s okay to evolve in your dietary choices. Trying different diets can help you learn about your body’s needs, but feeling pressured to stay in a restrictive eating plan because of fear, guilt, or social pressure isn’t healthy.
If you’re ready to approach your health journey with a balanced mindset that supports both your body and your lifestyle, consider booking a free nutrition audit. Together, we can assess your unique needs and create a sustainable plan that helps you achieve your goals without feeling like you’re trapped in a restrictive diet.
Comments